Thank you all for your fabulous, thoughtful responses regarding the question of "free will". I loved reading each of your thoughts and stories on the subject!
It appears we are mostly leaning in the direction of yes: yes, there is such a thing as free will. At the same time, we all suspect there are times when we make decisions in a state of mind that is less than completely "free". Case in point: the schizophrenic man who is off his meds and acting in a manner that he wouldn't if her were taking them...
Perhaps the "free" part is sometimes buried in so many layers of choices that we have trouble finding it in retrospect? There is a song by Casting Crowns called "Slow Fade" that speaks to this a bit. You can check it out here: http://www.reunionrecords.com/castingcrowns/slowfade/
I have a follow-up question, however. As a mom, I have long lamented the fact that our children may make immature, even childish decisions (an exercise of will) of which that, due to their immaturity, they may be incapable of grasping the significance/potential consequences.
Is it appropriate, then, to say that they have "free" will? Is decision-making truly free when one is unable to truly evaluate the potential outcome?
I don't know. Perhaps you have some thoughts?
One last thing I'd like to share as you ponder your response to this question:
The Casting Crowns song (above) incorporates the lyrics of an old children's hymn that kind of bothered me when I heard it. It goes something like this: "Be careful little eyes what you see (repeat). For the father up above is looking down with love; be careful little eyes what you see."
I confess that this song always seemed a bit, well, confusing to me. At once a warning (be careful what you see), simultaneously a promise of God's love (for the father up above is looking down with love). I was never sure what the lyricist meant by the juxtaposition of those two statements.
Recently I read a book in which the author talked about an experience he had with this song that he felt put it in to perspective. He was being driven through an extremely impoverished area by a missionary friend, assailed by the incredible challenges being faced by the people whom they passed on the road. Lack of permanent housing, food instability, poor health amid filthy conditions...
Then from the back seat of the car, the missionary's daughters, who had been singing children's songs to pass the time, started singing "Be careful little eyes what you see...Be careful little feet where you go...". And it struck the author then that this lyric was not so much a threat or admonition, but a plea to pay attention. A reminder to really SEE those who surround us and to remember that (1) God loves each of them, too, and (2) God wants us to act as conduits: to SEE and to ACT.
But back to children and free will: is it "informed" enough to be "free" will to those unable to grasp the consequences?
Inquiring minds want to know ;o)
A look at the ways in which our brains betray us: exploring neurological and mental health issues that interfere with our lives in large and small ways. We will share stories of how people cope with these disruptions and often triumph over them. I use my training as a neuroscientist, and my experience as the partner of an individual who suffers from narcolepsy with cataplexy, as a starting point for the discussion.
Thank you for visiting!
Thank you for visiting!
Showing posts with label God. Show all posts
Showing posts with label God. Show all posts
Saturday, September 25, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)